ChatGPT's Stock-Picking Army Should Make Us Nervous
When Jeremy Leung walked away from his Bloomberg terminal and two decades of UBS equity analysis, he didn't walk away from stock picking. He just...
The mall zombies have arrived—except this year, they're all talking to chatbots.
According to recent data reported by NBC News, 52% of consumers plan to use artificial intelligence for holiday shopping this year. That's not a niche early-adopter segment anymore. That's a majority of shoppers turning to AI to navigate gift lists, price tracking, and the overwhelming chaos of December retail.
Adobe Analytics reports a 500% increase in traffic from AI tools to retail sites, driven by aggressive new integrations from both AI platforms and major retailers. The shift isn't subtle. AI shopping has gone from experimental feature to mainstream behavior in a single holiday season.
OpenAI has struck partnerships with both Walmart and Target, allowing ChatGPT users to shop without ever leaving the chatbot interface. The workflow is almost too simple: Ask ChatGPT to find a Bluey doll for your five-year-old, and it returns product results directly in the conversation. Click to add items to cart, complete checkout—all native to the chat experience.
No tab-switching. No opening separate apps. The friction of "search, browse, decide, buy" collapses into a single conversational thread.
Google's Gemini has taken a different angle, offering price tracking with automated purchasing triggers. Set a target price for an item, provide your credit card information, and Gemini will execute the purchase when the price drops below your threshold—assuming you've consented to that level of automation.
The convenience is undeniable. The data implications are significant. We'll come back to that.
Beyond third-party AI platforms, major retailers have built their own chatbot assistants directly into their shopping apps and websites.
Amazon's Rufus acts as a constraint-based search filter with conversational input. Tell Rufus you want a soccer ball under $20, rated higher than 4.5 stars, deliverable in two days—and it surfaces matching products instantly. Amazon has also introduced "Help Me Decide," which monitors your browsing and purchase history to proactively recommend products when you seem indecisive. If you're clicking through multiple similar items without buying, Help Me Decide steps in with a specific recommendation based on your historical preferences.
Yes, this edges into surveillance territory. We're aware.
Walmart's Sparky takes a party-planning approach. Tell Sparky you're hosting a New Year's Eve gathering, and it generates a complete shopping cart with everything you'll need—decorations, food, supplies. You still have to approve and check out manually, but the cart assembly happens automatically based on event type and guest count.
Target's Gift Finder operates similarly, accepting parameters like recipient type, price range, and interest category to surface curated gift options.
The pattern across all three retailers: AI handles the tedious filtering and research phase, leaving humans to make the final purchase decision. It's assistive rather than fully autonomous, at least for now.
Holiday shopping isn't just about buying gifts—it's about managing the logistical nightmare of school recitals, office parties, family visits, and coordinating multiple schedules simultaneously.
OHI.AI addresses this directly by syncing multiple calendars into a single interface with AI-powered planning assistance. Lost track of which calendar has your dentist appointment? Ask OHI. Need to figure out what meal you can realistically prepare in the two-hour window between doctor's visit and soccer practice? OHI analyzes your schedule and suggests options that fit the time constraint.
The tool positions itself as a personal assistant for the calendar-overwhelmed—which, during the holidays, is essentially everyone.
But there's a cost. OHI isn't free, with premium tiers reaching $40 per month. And like all AI scheduling assistants, it requires access to deeply personal data—your location patterns, appointment history, family obligations, daily routines.
OHI's privacy policy states they won't sell your data to anyone outside their partners or parent company. Whether that's sufficiently reassuring depends on your comfort level with corporate data access generally.
Here's the uncomfortable truth underlying all of these AI shopping tools: They work by ingesting massive amounts of personal data.
Amazon's "Help Me Decide" requires browsing and purchase history. Walmart's Sparky needs to understand your household composition and entertaining habits. Google Gemini wants your credit card information and purchasing triggers. OHI demands full calendar access across every platform you use.
Each of these tools asks you to consent to data sharing as a condition of use. The convenience they offer is real. But you're paying with information—information about what you buy, when you buy it, how much you spend, who you're buying for, and how you structure your daily life.
The retailers and platforms argue this data stays within their ecosystems, used only to improve recommendations and streamline experiences. Privacy policies include language about not selling to third parties, though definitions of "partners" can be expansive.
For many consumers, the trade-off feels worth it. Holiday shopping is genuinely overwhelming. AI tools that reduce decision fatigue and save time deliver tangible value. But it's worth acknowledging what you're trading for that convenience.
The 500% increase in AI-driven retail traffic represents more than incremental adoption. It signals a fundamental shift in how consumers approach online shopping.
Previously, AI in retail meant recommendation algorithms running invisibly in the background—"customers who bought this also bought that." Now it means conversational interfaces that feel like shopping with an assistant who knows your preferences, budget constraints, and time pressures.
The experience is qualitatively different. You're not navigating menus and filters. You're delegating tasks to an agent that executes on your behalf.
For retailers, this creates both opportunity and risk. Opportunity: Chatbots reduce purchase friction and increase conversion rates. Risk: When customers shop primarily through AI interfaces, they're less exposed to impulse purchases, promotional displays, and the discovery mechanisms that drive unplanned spending.
A customer who asks ChatGPT for a specific product recommendation will buy that product—or nothing. They won't browse three adjacent categories and leave with unexpected items. That changes the economics of retail in ways we're only beginning to understand.
If 52% of consumers use AI shopping tools this year, expect that number to climb rapidly. The tools are improving. The integrations are deepening. And most importantly, consumers are discovering that AI-assisted shopping genuinely reduces the stress of gift-buying under time pressure.
By next holiday season, AI shopping won't be a trend—it will be default behavior for a majority of online shoppers.
The question isn't whether this happens. It's what retailers do in response. Do they double down on chatbot experiences, potentially sacrificing impulse purchase revenue? Do they fight to keep customers on traditional browsing interfaces? Do they find ways to reintroduce discovery and serendipity into AI-mediated shopping?
Those strategic questions will define retail competition in 2026 and beyond.
For now, if you're drowning in gift lists, calendar conflicts, and holiday logistics, the AI tools are here. They work. They'll save you time. Just remember what you're trading to get that time back.
If your organization is navigating the strategic implications of AI-mediated commerce and needs guidance on customer experience design, conversion optimization, or privacy-conscious growth strategies, Winsome Marketing's experts can help you build approaches that balance convenience with trust.
When Jeremy Leung walked away from his Bloomberg terminal and two decades of UBS equity analysis, he didn't walk away from stock picking. He just...
Watching retail investors hand over their financial futures to ChatGPT feels like witnessing a slow-motion car crash orchestrated by Silicon Valley's...
Target just announced they're bringing shopping to ChatGPT.